A Survey About a Voluntary Survey

By Jonathan Stettin November 16, 2026 6 min read Save Article

Shannon Arvin says aftercare is at an inflection point. Walt Robertson discusses strategic pillars. The release promises expanded services, coordination, and funding priorities.

Fine.

But we’re in November 2026. Aftercare isn’t a new issue. The industry has had decades to recognize its responsibility to horses once they can no longer produce revenue. Decades. And what landed in my inbox Monday morning was a survey.

The Thoroughbred Aftercare Alliance, the Retired Racehorse Project, Thoroughbred Charities of America and the National Thoroughbred Alliance launched the North American Thoroughbred Aftercare Stakeholder Survey, with The Jockey Club, Keeneland, Fasig-Tipton, OBS and the leading stallion farms behind it. The release calls it the first comprehensive industry survey focused on aftercare.

Read that again. The first. In a sport that has been running in this country for well over a century.

Coffee, Donuts and Kill Pens

I don’t doubt the people involved mean well. Some of them I know, and some of them I trust. But there is a disconnect here I can’t get past.

While we sit around a conference table over coffee and donuts talking about perceptions and practices, horses are standing in kill pens. Rescues are scraping to feed what they already have, and some of them can’t. Nobody needs a questionnaire to know that. Walk into any of those pens and you get the picture in about thirty seconds.

Arvin said what the industry lacks is a systematic, current picture of how the people responsible for the horses perceive and practice aftercare. Maybe. But the picture of the horses has been clear for a long time. That’s the part that should keep people up at night.

Where is the urgency?

Voluntary, Like Everything Else

Here’s what doesn’t sit right with me. This is a voluntary survey about a problem that has been treated as voluntary from the start.

Think about who fills it out. The people who already care. The trainer who calls around to find a home for a horse before he’s done. The breeder who pays to retrain one. The farm manager who keeps an old mare because she earned it. They’ll answer.

The guy who runs a horse until he’s worthless and lets him go out the back door to whoever is waiting? He isn’t filling out a stakeholder survey. So the results lean toward the converted, and the industry ends up studying the people who were never the problem.

That’s not a knock on the survey’s design. Breaking it down by professional role and region is the right way to do it, and asking about biases is smart. But a voluntary survey can only measure who volunteers.

The Question That Matters Most

If they’re going to do this, it has to be done in the open. So here’s my question for the working group, and it’s the one that matters more than all the others:

Will the results be published in full, including the uncomfortable findings, or selectively summarized?

If trainers say they don’t know where their horses end up, publish it. If breeders say aftercare is somebody else’s problem, publish it. If consignors admit they don’t ask who’s buying, publish it. If entire regions turn out to have no real aftercare infrastructure, publish that too.

A survey built to capture biases is worthless if the biases of the people releasing it decide what the rest of us get to read. Give us the full data broken down by role, not a press release with three bullet points and a nice photo of a retrained OTTB over a cross-rail.

The Rest of the Questions

There are others, and I’d like answers to them too.

How much money are we talking about? The release says Keeneland, Fasig-Tipton, OBS and several stallion farms committed a “significant funding increase” to the TAA earlier this year. It never says how much. If the number were impressive, it would have been in the headline.

Is it recurring, or one time? Aftercare isn’t a one-time expense. Horses retire every day.

Is it tied to the sales? The sales companies make money on every horse that goes through the ring. Is their aftercare commitment pegged to sales gross, or is it a flat check whatever the market does?

When does the survey close, and when do we see results? “Over the coming months” isn’t a deadline. It’s the kind of phrase that lets a clock run out.

Who’s analyzing the data? Someone independent, or the same organizations funding it?

Is a mandatory contribution on the table? A fee on every start and every sale, at every track and every auction, across North America. If the answer is no, then the industry is still asking for volunteers.

Where’s traceability? Kristin Werner of The Jockey Club said much of their work focuses on understanding what happens to horses throughout their lives and where the gaps are. I appreciate the honesty, because that is an admission that we still don’t reliably know. Not one word in the release about slaughter, kill pens, or tracking a horse after his last start. Those are the words that matter.

Credit Where It’s Due

I’m glad Pat Cummings is on this. The National Thoroughbred Alliance has a seat in the working group alongside The Jockey Club, Keeneland and Godolphin, and that matters. Pat’s quote is the only one in the release that sounds like somebody in a hurry. He called it a much-needed step forward, and he asked people to share the survey far and wide.

So I will. Fill it out. Share it. Especially if you work in a barn, on a farm, behind a sales ring, or at a rescue, because if the only people who answer are the ones who already care, the results will tell the industry exactly what it wants to hear. SURVEY LINK HERE

The working group has good people in it, including Jen Roytz, Kirsten Green and Erin Halliwell. I’m not questioning their commitment. I’m questioning the pace.

Weak

That’s how I see it. Not wrong, not bad. Weak.

A survey is a beginning, and in 2026 this industry shouldn’t still be beginning. The horses did their part. They ran, they bred, they made people money. They can’t fill out a questionnaire, and they can’t wait for the subcommittees to report back.

Publish everything. Put a number on the money. Make it mandatory. Then we’ll talk about inflection points.

As Jerry Maguire put it: show me the money.

Comments

Leave a Comment