The male three year old Eclipse Champion is

October 5, 2021

The latest horse racing results certainly raise three year old Eclipse Champion issues and debates

The Breeders’ Cup results should play a major role in the male three-year old Eclipse Champion

Are the Eclipse Awards really in California this year the same week as the Super Bowl? Anyway……

If we are going to be honest the Eclipse Awards don’t hold the prestige they once did. Perhaps for some they do, but for many racing fans and students of the game they just don’t. I’d argue earning your way into the Hall of Fame is a far more significant accomplishment for a horse, trainer or jockey. When you get a vote for California Chrome as the best turf horse a few years ago what do you really expect? Voters abstain, and some make up their minds based on geography and personal feelings. Case in point voters who have already said publicly they would not vote for Medina Spirit regardless of what happens on the racetrack. It is only fair to keep in mind the Medina Spirit Kentucky Derby betamethasone controversy likely will not be resolved by the time Eclipse votes are made. Some of the voters just look up stats and don’t even watch the races and follow the sport the way a voter should. The Eclipse Awards are watered down and need revamping. They are still the Eclipse Awards however and what looks like a foregone conclusion just might not be.

Now let’s get to the interesting stuff. That is where this year’s three-year old Eclipse Championship should be fun.

To many it seems Essential Quality is the clear cut best three-year old and last year’s two year old Eclipse Champion should have the edge this year. That makes sense right? Well how about if Medina Spirit with a smart gate to wire win over older horses in the win and you’re in Grade 1 Awesome Again comes back and wins the Breeders’ Cup Classic? That will make the big horse everyone thinks is little two for two over Essential Quality who many have already crowned. On resumes, Medina Spirit wins that contest. On personal feelings, who knows? Sure it is a what if, but this is horse racing and this is a what if column today.

Ah, if it was only that simple. What happens if Hot Rod Charlie blitzes the Classic leaving both Essential Quality and Medina Spirit in his wake? Is that enough to get him some votes? Well if California Chrome got a vote for turf horse that wasn’t a typo-o, and some voters won’t vote for the Eclipse Award for the top apprentice or steeplechase horse who knows.

How about this what if. None of the three-year olds win the Classic. Jackie’s Warrior blitzes older horses in the Sprint like plenty of crystal ball handicappers who can pick races before they are even drawn think he will, and they may be right, what happens then? Can he be three-year old champion? He’d certainly be dominant enough and have the resume of a champion. Can he be outright champion sprinter? Wouldn’t it be interesting to see either of those scenarios occur. You’d have a Steve Asmussen trained horse win an Eclipse the same year some of the voters who vote for him refuse to vote for Medina Spirit because of the Bob Baffert positive. I guess they won’t look up who has more positives between Steve Asmussen and Bob Baffert. If Jackie’s Warrior parlays a Breeders’ Cup win into a Grade 1 Malibu win that has to help his claim to fame especially if a three-year old does not win the Breeders’ Cup Classic.

This is a game of long-shots and beating the odds. Let’s say no three-year olds win the Classic, and Jackie’s Warrior goes down in the Breeders’ Cup Sprint. Far from an impossibility. Life is Good runs away and romps in the Breeders’ Cup Mile and comes back and he wins the Malibu, possibly beating Jackie’s Warrior. Under those circumstances can a case be made for him. he just may have truly been the best three-year old of them all this year had things gone his way. They didn’t and he is still here.

The race for the three-year old Eclipse Champion is an interesting one with what could turn out to be quite a few possibilities amongst some very talented horses. people like to talk about quality of the crops, I’d argue we have some really nice three-year olds this year. Dare I say anyone remember Following Sea?

While Essential Quality may be the favorite in the Breeders’ Cup Classic, or maybe second choice to Knicks Go, I would have to say Medina Spirit has the advantage over him for the “rights to the Eclipse Award.” Yes he will have to earn it on the racetrack but a second win over Essential Quality making him two for two against the two-year old champ by right earns him that trophy. If that plays out and he doesn’t win, you have to ask just what is the criteria to win that award anyway and what does it really mean?

And the winner is ______________! Feel free to cast your vote in the comments below. If you’re the first comment who gets it right you’ll get a free $100 win bet on next year’s Pegasus Stakes at Gulfstream Park.

Speaking of awards, there is a new award that is long overdue and as important to any in the sport. We celebrate our great equine athletes, jockeys, trainers and even owners. How about the workers on the backside? Don’t they deserve recognition and an award? We say yes and we are going to make that happen. We invite all fans and people in the industry to jump on board for our backstretch workers.

Read about, support, share and participate in the inaugural El Mejor Awards HERE

Our backstretch workers deserve it. Let’s make it happen for them!

Check out the best Breeders’ Cup live interactive seminar HERE, get your reservation, NOBODY DOES IT BETTER!

Contributing Authors

Jon Stettin

Jonathan’s always had a deep love and respect for the Sport of Kings. Growing up around the game, he came about as close as anyone...

View Jon Stettin

@jonathanstettin Your writing skills compare to Red Smith and Joe Hirsch- Just a wonderful read

howard eder (@bbopjz) View testimonials

Facebook

Comments

  1. David Spinelli Oct 5, 2021 at 9:09 am

    Of course it is still too early to crown the winner. The top three front runners would have to be Essential Quality, Medina Spirit and Jackie’s Warrior.

  2. David Spinelli Oct 5, 2021 at 9:10 am

    Of course it is still too early to crown the winner. The top three front runners would have to be Essential Quality, Medina Spirit and Jackie’s Warrior.
    I am leaning toward Jackie’s Warrior!

    1. Jonathan Stettin Oct 5, 2021 at 9:43 am

      I kinda agree as of today, let’s see what happens at the BC.

  3. Chad Swift Oct 5, 2021 at 10:42 am

    Essential Quality

  4. Karen E Villarreal Oct 5, 2021 at 12:56 pm

    Essential Quality or maybe Medina Spirit,
    especially if MS wins the BCC.

  5. Karen L Rogers Oct 8, 2021 at 12:02 am

    Life is Good is the best 3 year old, but he probably won’t get the Award. Awards don’t get you the best mares, however! Speed and talent do–and he is THAT horse!

  6. Erin Stockmann Oct 8, 2021 at 1:16 am

    Media Spirit !

  7. Erin Stockmann Oct 8, 2021 at 1:18 am

    Medina Spirit

  8. Cathy Beck Oct 11, 2021 at 7:32 pm

    Medina Spirit! #teambaffert #IstandwithBob #IstandwithMedinaSpirit

  9. Nancy Urbanczyk Oct 11, 2021 at 11:36 pm

    Medina Spirit

  10. Victoria Andrews Oct 12, 2021 at 12:25 am

    Medina Spirit

  11. joani jiannine Oct 12, 2021 at 3:40 am

    Thank you for your column! It’s a tough call on HOTY this year, but I lets see who wins what and lot’s of eyes on the Classic, as you say. but I am rooting for Medina Spirit…

  12. Leonard (Forego 137) Oct 12, 2021 at 4:26 am

    MEDINA SPIRT…. HE’S FRESH, IMPROVING & HIS AWESOME AGAIN TOUR D’FORCE LET EVERYONE KNOW WE STILL HAVEN’T SEEN HIS BEST YET. LOOK FOR ANOTHER BIG STEP FORWARD IN B.C.C. & HANDS DOWN THE TOP 3YO OUT THERE & HORSE OF THE YEAR BECAUSE HE’S ALSO THE BEST HORSE IN TRAINING IN 2021.

  13. Linda Rowell Oct 12, 2021 at 7:35 am

    Medina Spirit.if he wins BC And a tacky hit on California Chrome’s win …

    1. Jonathan Stettin Oct 12, 2021 at 7:51 am

      No Linda, LOL, it was a hit on the vote for turf horse not the horse himself.

  14. Lowell Rikart Oct 12, 2021 at 10:01 am

    Clearly it’s Medina Spirir

  15. Nancy Cowan Oct 17, 2021 at 9:53 pm

    Medina Spirit !

Leave a Comment