Get your reservation for our annual Kentucky Derby seminar now! Details Here
A follow-up to The Thinking Cap Piece: Credit where it’s due — and the structural questions that don’t go away.
We said the room where means and will exist simultaneously has historically been empty in this sport.
NYRA just walked in.
Tony Allevato, NYRA’s chief revenue officer and president of NYRA Bets, told TDN this week that his team is actively working to fill the void left by FanDuel TV’s announced wind-down — and he said it five days after the announcement, which in racing industry time is roughly equivalent to breaking a sound barrier. Stakes coverage from Keeneland and Oaklawn will appear on America’s Day at the Races as soon as April 11. Fox is engaged. A second channel concept is on the table. A multi-track, RedZone-style digital product is being sketched out.
That deserves acknowledgment. We will give it.
It also deserves honest scrutiny. We will give that too. That’s what we’re here for.
CREDIT WHERE IT IS DUE
Let’s be direct about what NYRA and Fox have already built, because it’s easy to take it for granted: roughly 1,000 hours of racing television in 2025 across Fox and its affiliate sports networks, anchored by America’s Day at the Races, Saratoga Live, and the Belmont Stakes broadcast. That is a real infrastructure, run by real professionals, with a real audience. Allevato spent years as an executive producer at TVG before coming to NYRA. He knows what this business looks like from the inside.
When Allevato says he wants to grow that platform to pick up stakes racing from tracks that FanDuel TV was carrying — Keeneland, Oaklawn, and others — he is not speaking abstractly. He has a production apparatus to do it with and a broadcast partner that has demonstrated a long-term commitment to the sport. That combination is genuinely rare. Most of the people who will volunteer opinions about who should replace FanDuel TV do not have either.
The April 11 card is a meaningful first step. Keeneland on Fox is not a small thing. If it holds and expands, it matters.
WHAT HE’S DESCRIBING, AND WHAT IT ISN’T
Here’s where we stay honest, because that’s the job.
What Allevato is describing is premium supplement coverage — major stakes, top-tier content, quality over quantity. That is a Fox Sports philosophy, and it is the right philosophy for Fox. It is not, structurally, what FanDuel TV was.
FanDuel TV was wall-to-wall. Everyday racing. Commentary across the card. A place you could go on a random Tuesday at Aqueduct and find someone who gave a damn about the race on screen. That product — accessible, daily, opinionated, free — was a genuine fan development pipeline, however imperfect. It was also, if we are being fully honest, a loss leader that made economic sense only because Flutter Entertainment had a strategic ADW interest in racing’s audience. When that interest evaporated, so did the model.
NYRA cannot and should not try to rebuild that product directly. Allevato is right not to promise it. What he’s promising is different, and that honesty is worth crediting.
The hole in daily coverage is still a hole. Acknowledging it isn’t criticism of what NYRA is doing. It’s a description of the landscape they’re working in.
THE REDZONE IDEA IS ACTUALLY RIGHT
I want to spend a moment on the concept Allevato floated — the multi-track, RedZone-style product that bounces from race to race with a host or two, living on a digital platform accessible across ADWs, sportsbooks, and general consumers.
I think that’s the most interesting idea in the conversation right now. Not because it solves the structural economics — it doesn’t, not by itself — but because it fits how people actually consume sports content in 2026.
The NFL RedZone works because it meets the modern viewer where they are: shorter attention spans, multiple screens, a desire for action over narrative. You are not watching a three-hour game. You are watching every touchdown as it happens, contextualized by a host who knows the stakes. It is efficient, it is addictive, and it is the reason NFL RedZone has a more passionate subscriber base than many standalone networks.
Horse racing is, structurally, a better RedZone sport than football. The action is concentrated. A race is ninety seconds. The gaps between races are built for commentary and transition. A host who can move from Keeneland to Oaklawn to Laurel in real time, with genuine knowledge and genuine enthusiasm, is not filling time — they are building exactly the kind of moment-to-moment engagement that turns a casual viewer into a horseplayer.
Racing is structurally a better RedZone sport than football. The action is ninety seconds. The gaps are built for transition. The format fits the moment.
The challenge isn’t the concept. It’s the economics behind it. A digital RedZone product without an attached wagering solution that benefits from the audience it builds is, as I argued in The Thinking Cap Piece, a marketing expense for someone else’s betting product. If NYRA Bets or a genuine wagering innovation captures the revenue generated by that audience, the model has a chance. If it routes to TwinSpires by default, NYRA is building audience for Churchill Downs Incorporated. That is a conversation worth having openly before the cameras are pointed.
WHAT HASN’T CHANGED
The structural argument we made in The Thinking Cap Piece stands intact. The sport is fragmented. CDI’s platform interests are not aligned with a competitor building audience. The host fee structure means any media operation is paying the tracks it covers, which inverts the economics of every other media model. Exchange wagering — or something that meaningfully changes the revenue architecture — remains the only idea on the table that fixes the math rather than working around it.
Allevato himself was careful about scope. He noted that once the Saratoga meet starts, NYRA’s focus narrows. He said the multi-track product is still being sketched. He called the situation ‘very fluid’ multiple times. A man who has lived through the TVG layoffs of the Gray Davis era — and who clearly has not forgotten that phone call from Mark Wilson at the Arc — is not going to overpromise on a racing media build.
We are not going to overpromise either. What NYRA and Fox are doing is the best available response from the best-positioned actor in the space. It is not a structural solution. It is a serious, professional attempt to extend a proven platform into a void that is larger than any one platform can fill.
That’s worth respecting. It does not end the conversation.
THE ROOM IS LESS EMPTY THAN IT WAS
We ended The Thinking Cap Piece by noting that the people with both the means and the will have rarely occupied the same room at the same time in horse racing.
NYRA has means. The Fox partnership gives them distribution infrastructure that nobody else in the sport can match right now. Allevato has will — and more importantly, he has the institutional memory to know what can go wrong and why.
The room is less empty than it was last week. That’s real progress. We’ll take it.
Now build the thing. The RedZone model, done right, with a wagering product attached that actually benefits from the audience being built — that’s the version we’ve been waiting for. Not because we’re optimistic by nature. Because we did the math, and it’s the one version that works.
We’ll be watching. And unlike some of the institutions we cover, we’ll tell you exactly what we see.
Related: The Thinking Cap Piece | pastthewire.com
Related: The Billion Dollar Question Nobody Wants to Answer | pastthewire.com
If You Build It They Will Come:
