Bye Bye Melvin Under Consideration for Breeders’ Cup Turf

October 9, 2022

OZONE PARK, N.Y.— Bye Bye Melvin put to rest any doubts trainer Graham Motion had about the 5-year-old son of Uncle Mo stretching out to 12 furlongs with a game pacesetting second in Saturday’s 12-furlong Grade 1 Joe Hirsch Turf Classic.

The Alex M. Campbell, Jr. homebred equaled his career-best 101 Beyer with his runner-up effort to War Like Goddess, logging the same number in his previous effort when a wire-to-wire winner going nine furlongs on September 1 at Saratoga Race Course.

Guided by Feargal Lynch, Bye Bye Melvin logged honest splits of 24.25 seconds, 48.96, 1:13.68 and 1:39.10, and battled gamely in mid-stretch when challenged by War Like Goddess to finish 2 3/4 lengths in arrears of the dual Grade 1-winning mare.

“Considering it was his first time doing that, I thought it was very impressive. It was fairly obvious on paper that he’d be on the lead and Feargal did a good job with him,” Motion said.

The Joe Hirsch Turf Classic was Bye Bye Melvin’s third start off a 14-month layoff. Prior to his September victory, he was a close fourth beaten a neck in July at Saratoga in a race won by next-out graded stakes winner Emaraaty. This was his first start since finishing a well-beaten tenth in the Grade 1 Manhattan in June 2021 at 10 furlongs, which prior to the Joe Hirsch was the furthest he had traveled.

Out of the Grade 1-winning Dynaformer mare Karlovy Vary, Bye Bye Melvin is a half-brother to multiple graded stakes-winning turf stayer Mean Mary, by Scat Daddy, who was also conditioned by Motion.

“I was a little concerned [regarding stamina] just because of the Uncle Mo on top, whereas she was by Scat Daddy,” Motion said. “You never quite know. His one race going a mile and a quarter was a little disappointing, but I don’t think he was doing as well then as he is now. He’s some animal. In the flesh, he’s an impressive-looking individual.”

Motion said a rematch with War Like Goddess in the 12-furlong Grade 1, $4 million Breeders’ Cup Turf on November 5 at Keeneland will be under consideration for Bye Bye Melvin. Motion previously captured the Turf with Better Talk Now [2004] and Main Sequence [2014].

“We’ll take a look at the Breeders Cup,” Motion said. “We ran Mean Mary [seventh in the 2020 Filly and Mare Turf] and things didn’t work out. I don’t think it was through any fault of her own. But I feel like there’s no reason not to give it a try. It’s Mr. Campbell’s home track, and this is what it’s all about. The horse who beat him yesterday will be the favorite in whichever race she goes in.”

NYRA Press Office

Photo: Bye Bye Melvin (inside) leads them into the turn in the G1 Joe Hirsch Turf Classic (Dom Napolitano)


For information on Past The Wire’s annual Breeders’ Cup Seminar, the very best in the game CLICK HERE

This article is a must read. 1st ballot Hall of Fame horseplayer, generous teacher and heralded writer! Thanks John. twitter.com/jonathanstetti…

Michael R. Snow (@theWynnDough) View testimonials

Facebook